In this paper, the closed-loop supply chain bullwhip effect as the research object, according to the bullwhip effect value comparison shows the existence of reverse supply chain can reduce the bullwhip effect, and recovery products rate is higher, the effect of reducing the bullwhip effect is more obvious. In demand mutations conditions, recovery products rate higher the bullwhip effect in favor weakened. In the random demand conditions, with the recovery products rate increases, suppliers bullwhip effect decreased significantly.