Preclinical evaluation of PARP inhibition in breast cancer: Comparative effectiveness of olaparib and iniparib.
1042 Background: The main function of PARP1 is repair of single-strand DNA. Phase I/II clinical trials have shown that the PARP inhibitor, olaparib has efficacy in BRCA1/2-related breast cancer. Due to the similarities between BRCA1/2-associated and triple negative breast cancer (TNBC), we hypothesise that TNBC may also be sensitive to PARP inhibition. In order to assess this we addressed the effects of 2 PARP/PARP-like inhibitors, on a panel of breast cancer cell lines. Methods: PARP1 was measured by immunohistochemistry in 101 TNBC and 116 non-TN cancers. Comparative growth inhibitory capacity of olaparib and iniparib was evaluated using cell viability (MTT) and colony formation assays in 12 breast cancer cell lines (TN=7, non-TN=5). Results: Using immunohistochemistry, PARP1 staining was predominantly nuclear with some cytoplasmic staining. High staining intensity for PARP1 was found more frequently in ER-negative (p = 0.001), in high grade (p = 0.013) and in Ki67-positive ( p = 0.003) samples. Potentially important was the finding that high PARP1 staining intensity was detected more frequently in TN than non-TN samples (p = 0.0001). IC50 concentrations across 12 cell lines ranged from 3.7-31 µM for olaparib and 13-70 µM for iniparib. No difference in sensitivity was observed between the TN and non-TN cell lines (by MTT). Olaparib also reduced the ability of cells to form colonies with IC50 values ranging from <0.01-2.5 µM. Addition of the CDKI inhibitor CDK1i (Calbiochem) to olaparib resulted in formation of significantly fewer colonies compared with either inhibitor alone, in a cell line dependent manner. Conclusions: Our results suggest that although PARP1 is expressed in the majority of breast cancer, significantly higher staining intensity was found in TN than non-TN samples. Furthermore, our work suggests that olaparib is a more potent inhibitor of the in vitro growth of breast cancer cells than iniparib. Combined inhibition of PARP1 with olaparib and CDK1 with CDK1i may be a way forward for the treatment of TNBC. Acknowledgement: The authors thank SFI (SRC award, 08/SRC/B1410 MTCI) for funding this work.