Abstract
Study question
What is the effect of varying diagnostic thresholds on the accuracy of Next Generation Sequencing (NGS)-based preimplantation genetic testing for aneuploidies (PGT-A)?
Summary answer
When single trophectoderm biopsies are tested, the employment of 80% upper threshold increases mosaic calls and false negative aneuploidy results compared to more stringent thresholds.
What is known already
Trophectoderm (TE) biopsy coupled with NGS-based PGT-A technologies are able to accurately predict Inner Cell Mass’ (ICM) constitution when uniform whole chromosome aneuploidies are considered. However, minor technical and biological inconsistencies in NGS procedures and biopsy specimens can result in subtle variability in analytical results. In this context, the stringency of thresholds employed for diagnostic calls can lead to incorrect classification of uniformly aneuploid embryos into the mosaic category, ultimately affecting PGT-A accuracy. In this study, we evaluated the diagnostic predictivity of different aneuploidy classification criteria by employing blinded analysis of chromosome copy number values (CNV) in multifocal blastocyst biopsies.
Study design, size, duration
The accuracy of different aneuploidy diagnostic cut-offs was assessed comparing chromosomal CNV in intra-blastocysts multifocal biopsies. Enrolled embryos were donated for research between June and September 2020. The Institutional Review Board at the Near East University approved the study (project: YDU/20l9/70–849). Embryos diagnosed with uniform chromosomal alterations (single or multiple) in their clinical TE biopsy (n = 27) were disaggregated into 5 portions: the ICM and 4 TE biopsies. Overall, 135 specimens were collected and analysed.
Participants/materials, setting, methods
Twenty-seven donated blastocysts were warmed and disaggregated in TE biopsies and ICM (n = 135 biopsies). PGT-A analysis was performed using Ion ReproSeq PGS kit and Ion S5 sequencer (ThermoFisher). Sequencing data were blindly analysed with Ion-Reporter software. Intra-blastocyst comparison of raw NGS data was performed employing different thresholds commonly used for aneuploidy classification. CNV for each chromosome were reported as aneuploid according to 70% or 80% thresholds. Categorical variables were compared using Fisher’s exact test.
Main results and the role of chance
In this study, a total of 50 aneuploid patterns in 27 disaggregated embryos were explored. Single TE biopsy results were considered as true positive when they displayed the same alteration detected in the ICM at levels above the 70% or 80% thresholds. Alternatively, alterations detected in the euploid or mosaic range were considered as false negative aneuploidy results. When the 70% threshold was applied, aneuploidy findings were confirmed in 94.5% of TE biopsies analyzed (n = 189/200; 95%CI=90.37–37.22), while 5.5% showed a mosaic profile (50–70%) but uniformly abnormal ICM. Positive (PPV) and negative predictive value (NPV) per chromosome were 100.0% (n = 189/189; 95%CI=98.07–100.00) and 99.5% (n = 2192/2203; 95%CI=99.11–99.75) respectively. When the upper cut-off was experimentally placed at 80% of abnormal cells, a significant decrease (p-value=0.0097) in the percentage of confirmed aneuploid calls was observed (86.5%; n = 173/200; 95%CI=80.97–90.91), resulting in mosaicism overcalling, especially in the high range (50–80%). Less stringent thresholds led to extremely high PPV (100.0%; n = 173/173; 95%CI=97.89–100.00), while NPV decreased to 98.8% (n = 2192/2219; 95%CI=98.30–99.23). Furthermore, no additional true mosaic patterns were identified with the use of wide range thresholds for aneuploidy classification.
Limitations, reasons for caution
This approach involved the analysis of aneuploidy CNV thresholds at the embryo level and lacked from genotyping-based confirmation analysis. Moreover, aneuploid embryos with known meiotic partial deletion/duplication were not included.
Wider implications of the findings: The use of wide thresholds for detecting intermediate chromosomal CNV up to 80% doesn’t improve PGT-A ability to discriminate true mosaic from uniformly aneuploid embryos, lowering overall diagnostic accuracy. Hence, a proportion of the embryos diagnosed as mosaic using wide calling thresholds may actually be uniformly aneuploid and inadvertently transferred.
Trial registration number
N/A
Rationale for endomyocardial biopsy in the diagnosis of heart disease in children and adults