Inventing Rabbis

Early Judaism ◽  
2018 ◽  
pp. 199-226
Author(s):  
Christine Hayes

The origin of rabbinic Judaism and its rise to dominance were debated in antiquity as they are today. Although the rabbis saw themselves as direct heirs of biblical religion and traced their understanding of Torah to Sinai, they presented a form of Judaism that could function without the Temple, which had been destroyed by the Romans in 70 CE. Breaking from previous generations’ polemical views, some modern scholars regard them as the group which emerged triumphant after that event, while others see the rabbis as having created a grand coalition of several earlier forms of Jewish expression.

1987 ◽  
Vol 80 (2) ◽  
pp. 133-160 ◽  
Author(s):  
L. Michael White

Recent studies and archaeological work have focused attention once again on an old problem—the origins and development of the synagogue—by bringing two sides of the issue to light. On the one hand, some studies have reconsidered theories of synagogue origins in the Babylonian, Persian, or Hellenistic periods. The result is that several traditional assumptions typified in the works of Julian Morgenstern, Solomon Zeitlin, George Foot Moore, and Louis Finkelstein have been questioned. The question of origins has come to rest on the Palestinian setting and on the nature of the “synagogue” not as institution in the later Talmudic sense, but as “assembly.” There is no clear archaeological evidence for synagogue buildings from Second Temple Palestine. Only after 70 CE and the destruction of the Temple, did it emerge as the central institution of Pharisaic-Rabbinic Judaism.


2005 ◽  
Vol 4 (1) ◽  
pp. 109-134
Author(s):  
Joshua Kulp

Emerging methods in the study of rabbinic literature now enable greater precision in dating the individual components of the Passover seder and haggadah. These approaches, both textual and socio-historical, have led to a near consensus among scholars that the Passover seder as described in rabbinic literature did not yet exist during the Second Temple period. Hence, cautious scholars no longer seek to find direct parallels between the last supper as described in the Gospels and the rabbinic seder. Rather, scholarly attention has focused on varying attempts of Jewish parties, notably rabbis and Christians, to provide religious meaning and sanctity to the Passover celebration after the death of Jesus and the destruction of the Temple. Three main forces stimulated the rabbis to develop innovative seder ritual and to generate new, relevant exegeses to the biblical Passover texts: (1) the twin calamities of the destruction of the Jerusalem Temple and the Bar-Kokhba revolt; (2) competition with emerging Christian groups; (3) assimilation of Greco-Roman customs and manners. These forces were, of course, significant contributors to the rise of a much larger array of rabbinic institutions, ideas and texts. Thus surveying scholarship on the seder reviews scholarship on the emergence of rabbinic Judaism.


Author(s):  
Stefan C. Reif

In the second Temple period, Jewish ritual and worship, following the example of the Hebrew Bible, centered on the cult of the Jerusalem Temple and on the more democratic institution of individual prayer, but the two elements had drawn closer to each other by the axial age. In their campaign to establish formal communal prayer as a theological priority, leading rabbis of the first two centuries were inspired not only by those two precedents but also by biblical formulas, the example set at Qumran, the notion of the berakhah, and by the development of the synagogue, which added prayer to its earlier interest in study, social activity, and the hosting of visitors. The shema’, ‘amidah, and birkat ha-mazon, as well as qiddush, havdalah, hallel, and the Passover Haggadah, were early components of rabbinic liturgy, and these gradually moved from the domestic and individual contexts to the synagogue and community. Towards the end of the talmudic period, liturgical poetry and mysticism, especially from the Jewish homeland, were incorporated into standard rabbinic prayers, but not until the ninth and tenth centuries did rabbinic leaders in Babylonia succeed in transforming the oral prayers into the written prayer-book. Although use was limited of the Hebrew Bible and lists of sacrifices from the earliest rabbinic liturgy, such scriptural readings acquired a more important, structured role in the late talmudic, post-talmudic, and early medieval periods. Although the temple service and priesthood figured in the liturgical poems, they had lost much of their status as spiritual intermediaries.


Author(s):  
Dalia Marx ◽  
David Levine

The influence of the Jerusalem Temple and its rituals persisted in Jewish religious expression even after its destruction. Reactions to this religious rift incorporated the Temple experience as an ongoing resource. The complex and multifaceted transition from Temple to synagogue, and from priests to rabbis, regarded the Temple and its cult as a validating component. The Temple and its attendant practices were present in the assorted domains of rabbinic ritual law. Whether dealing with issues of purity, tithing, prayer, holidays, or home rituals, different strategies were employed when appealing to Temple practice: maintaining continuity, modifying and adapting to changed circumstances, acknowledging break and rupture, and suggesting new modes of religious expression. As in other areas, rabbinic ritual law is marked by its progression toward comprehensiveness, systemization, and abstraction, and it is a foundational stage in the trajectory of Jewish law and practice regarding ritual.


2020 ◽  
Vol 51 (3) ◽  
pp. 398-431
Author(s):  
Moshe Simon-Shoshan

Abstract The Palestinian version of the seventy-year sleep of Honi Hamʿagel in y. Taʿanit 3:9 (66d), is an example of a rabbinic narrative deeply rooted in the culture of pre-rabbinic Judaism. Its authors were familiar with three distinct literary-historical traditions found in earlier texts: the depiction of Simon the high priest in Ben Sira; the account of Nehemiah hiding and restoring the fire of the temple altar in 2 Maccabees; and the story of Abimelech’s decades-long nap preserved in 4 Baruch and The History of the Babylonian Captivity. These three traditions were already connected to each other as part of a wider network of texts, traditions, and collective memory about the Babylonian exile and the return to Zion. The creators of the Honi story built on and extended this body of cultural materials, creating an original work about the continuity of Jewish life and tradition from the biblical era to their own.


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document