scholarly journals A Comparative Study on Fault Detection Methods for Gas Turbine Combustion Systems

Energies ◽  
2021 ◽  
Vol 14 (2) ◽  
pp. 389
Author(s):  
Jinfu Liu ◽  
Zhenhua Long ◽  
Mingliang Bai ◽  
Linhai Zhu ◽  
Daren Yu

As one of the core components of gas turbines, the combustion system operates in a high-temperature and high-pressure adverse environment, which makes it extremely prone to faults and catastrophic accidents. Therefore, it is necessary to monitor the combustion system to detect in a timely way whether its performance has deteriorated, to improve the safety and economy of gas turbine operation. However, the combustor outlet temperature is so high that conventional sensors cannot work in such a harsh environment for a long time. In practical application, temperature thermocouples distributed at the turbine outlet are used to monitor the exhaust gas temperature (EGT) to indirectly monitor the performance of the combustion system, but, the EGT is not only affected by faults but also influenced by many interference factors, such as ambient conditions, operating conditions, rotation and mixing of uneven hot gas, performance degradation of compressor, etc., which will reduce the sensitivity and reliability of fault detection. For this reason, many scholars have devoted themselves to the research of combustion system fault detection and proposed many excellent methods. However, few studies have compared these methods. This paper will introduce the main methods of combustion system fault detection and select current mainstream methods for analysis. And a circumferential temperature distribution model of gas turbine is established to simulate the EGT profile when a fault is coupled with interference factors, then use the simulation data to compare the detection results of selected methods. Besides, the comparison results are verified by the actual operation data of a gas turbine. Finally, through comparative research and mechanism analysis, the study points out a more suitable method for gas turbine combustion system fault detection and proposes possible development directions.

Author(s):  
G. J. Kelsall ◽  
M. A. Smith ◽  
H. Todd ◽  
M. J. Burrows

Advanced coal based power generation systems such as the British Coal Topping Cycle offer the potential for high efficiency electricity generation with minimum environmental impact. An important component of the Topping Cycle programme is the development of a gas turbine combustion system to burn low calorific value (3.5–4.0 MJ/m3 wet gross) coal derived fuel gas, at a turbine inlet temperature of 1260°C, with minimum pollutant emissions. The paper gives an overview of the British Coal approach to the provision of a gas turbine combustion system for the British Coal Topping Cycle, which includes both experimental and modelling aspects. The first phase of this programme is described, including the design and operation of a low-NOx turbine combustor, operating at an outlet temperature of 1360°C and burning a synthetic low calorific value (LCV) fuel gas, containing 0 to 1000 ppmv of ammonia. Test results up to a pressure of 8 bar are presented and the requirements for further combustor development outlined.


Author(s):  
William D. York ◽  
Bryan W. Romig ◽  
Michael J. Hughes ◽  
Derrick W. Simons ◽  
Joseph V. Citeno

Operators of heavy duty gas turbines desire more flexibility of operation in compliance with increasingly stringent emissions regulations. Delivering low NOx at base load operation, while at the same time meeting aggressive startup, shutdown, and part load requirements for NOx, CO, and unburned hydrocarbons is a challenge that requires novel solutions in the framework of lean premixed combustion systems. The DLN2.6+ combustion system, first offered by the General Electric Company (GE) in 2005 on the 9F series gas turbines for the 50 Hz market, has a proven track record of low emissions, flexibility, and reliability. In 2010, GE launched a program to incorporate the DLN2.6+ into the 7F gas turbine model. The primary driver for the introduction of this combustion system into the 60 Hz market was to enable customers to capitalize on opportunities to use shale gas, which may have a greater Wobbe range and higher reactivity than traditional natural gas. The 7F version of the DLN2.6+ features premixed pilot flames on the five outer swirl-stabilized premixing fuel nozzles (“swozzles”). The premixed pilots have their roots in the multitube mixer technology developed by GE in the US Department of Energy Hydrogen Gas Turbine Program. A fraction of air is extracted prior to entering the combustor and sent to small tubes around the tip of the fuel nozzle centerbody. A dedicated pilot fuel circuit delivers the gas fuel to the pilot tubes, where it is injected into the air stream and given sufficient length to mix. Since the pilot flames are premixed, they contribute lower NOx emissions than a diffusion pilot, but can still provide enhanced main circuit flame stability at low-load conditions. The pilot equivalence ratio can be optimized for the specific operating conditions of the gas turbine. This paper presents the development and validation testing of the premixed pilots, which were tested on E-class and F-class gas turbine combustion system rigs at GE Power & Water’s Gas Turbine Technology Lab. A 25% reduction in NOx emissions at nominal firing temperature was demonstrated over a diffusion flame pilot, translating into more than 80% reduction in CO emissions if increased flame temperature is employed to hold constant NOx. On the new 7F DLN2.6+, the premixed pilots have enabled modifications to the system to reduce base load NOx emissions while maintaining similar gas turbine low-load performance and bringing a significant reduction in the combustor exit temperature at which LBO occurs, highlighting the stability the pilot system brings to the combustor without the NOx penalty of a diffusion pilot. The new combustion system is scheduled to enter commercial operation on GE 7F series gas turbines in 2015.


Author(s):  
Jeffrey Price ◽  
Josh Kimmel ◽  
Xiaoqun Chen ◽  
Arun Bhattacharya ◽  
Anthony Fahme ◽  
...  

Solar Turbines Incorporated (Solar), under cooperative agreement number DE-FC26-00CH 11049, is improving the durability of gas turbine combustion systems while reducing life cycle costs. This project is part of the Advanced Materials in Advanced Industrial Gas Turbines program in DOE’s Office of Distributed Energy. The targeted engine is the Mercury™ 50 gas turbine, which was developed by Solar under the DOE Advanced Turbine Systems (ATS) program (DOE contract number DE-FC21-95MC31173). The ultimate goal of the program is to demonstrate a fully integrated Mercury 50 combustion system, modified with advanced materials technologies, at a host site for 4,000 hours. The program has focused on a dual path development route to define an optimum mix of technologies for the Mercury 50 turbine and future Solar products. For liner and injector development, multiple concepts including high thermal resistance thermal barrier coatings (TBC), oxide dispersion strengthened (ODS) alloys, continuous fiber ceramic composites (CFCC), and monolithic ceramics were evaluated. An advanced TBC system for the combustor was down-selected for field evaluation. ODS alloys were down-selected for the fuel injector tip application. Preliminary component and sub-scale testing was conducted to determine material properties and demonstrate proof-of-concept. Full-scale rig and engine testing were used to validate engine performance prior to field evaluation. Field evaluation of ceramic matrix composite liners in the Centaur® 50 gas turbine engine [1–3] which was previously conducted under the DOE sponsored Ceramic Stationary Gas Turbine program (DE-AC02-92CE40960), is continuing under this program. This paper is a status review of the program, detailing the current progress of the development and field evaluations.


Author(s):  
J. Zelina ◽  
D. T. Shouse ◽  
J. S. Stutrud ◽  
G. J. Sturgess ◽  
W. M. Roquemore

An aero gas turbine engine has been proposed that uses a near-constant-temperature (NCT) cycle and an Inter-Turbine Burner (ITB) to provide large amounts of power extraction from the low-pressure turbine. This level of energy is achieved with a modest temperature rise across the ITB. The additional energy can be used to power a large geared fan for an ultra-high bypass ratio transport aircraft, or to drive an alternator for large amounts of electrical power extraction. Conventional gas turbines engines cannot drive ultra-large diameter fans without causing excessively high turbine temperatures, and cannot meet high power extraction demands without a loss of engine thrust. Reducing the size of the combustion system is key to make use of a NCT gas turbine cycle. Ultra-compact combustor (UCC) concepts are being explored experimentally. These systems use high swirl in a circumferential cavity about the engine centerline to enhance reaction rates via high cavity g-loading on the order of 3000 g’s. Any increase in reaction rate can be exploited to reduce combustor volume. The UCC design integrates compressor and turbine features which will enable a shorter and potentially less complex gas turbine engine. This paper will present experimental data of the Ultra-Compact Combustor (UCC) performance in vitiated flow. Vitiation levels were varied from 12–20% oxygen levels to simulate exhaust from the high pressure turbine (HPT). Experimental results from the ITB at atmospheric pressure indicate that the combustion system operates at 97–99% combustion efficiency over a wide range of operating conditions burning JP-8 +100 fuel. Flame lengths were extremely short, at about 50% of those seen in conventional systems. A wide range of operation is possible with lean blowout fuel-air ratio limits at 25–50% below the value of current systems. These results are significant because the ITB only requires a small (300°F) temperature rise for optimal power extraction, leading to operation of the ITB at near-lean-blowout limits of conventional combustor designs. This data lays the foundation for the design space required for future engine designs.


Author(s):  
Hasan Karim ◽  
Jayaprakash Natarajan ◽  
Venkat Narra ◽  
Jun Cai ◽  
Shreekrishna Rao ◽  
...  

Driven by global warming, a relentless march towards increased fuel efficiency has resulted in increased firing temperature for HA-class engines without an increase in baseload emissions. Moreover, emissions compliance for CO, NOx, and unburned hydrocarbons are desired over increased range in gas turbine load. In addition, exceptional gas turbine operational flexibility is desired to address potential intermittency due to the penetration of renewables in the electrical grid. Staged/sequential combustion is a state of the technology to provide operational flexibility and reduced emissions in power generation gas turbines. GE Power’s 7HA-class gas turbine combustion system combines GE’s proven DLN-2.6+ combustion technology, that has run reliably for over 1.3 million fired hours across more than eighty 9FA.03, 9F.05 & 7FA gas turbine engines, with an axially fuel staged system (AFS). Axially staging combustion to two zones allows for increased firing temperature at baseload (while maintaining the same NOx level) by operating the later/second stage hotter than the first/primary stage. During low load operation as the gas turbine firing temperature is reduced, percentage fuel split in the staged fuel system can either be reduced significantly or turned off and thereby keeping the overall combustion system into emissions compliance over a wider range of firing temperatures. This paper presents both the development testing of the staged combustion in the FA and HA class gas turbine combustion system rigs at GE Power’s Gas Turbine Technology Laboratory and the validation testing of staged combustion system for the 7HA.01 engine completed during Spring 2016 at GE Power’s engine test facility in Greenville, SC. The paper also discusses the significant simplification of operational principle and flexibility of startup, loading and baseload operation of the 7HA combustion system. Discussion of engine test results will show how axial fuel staging was utilized to demonstrate emissions compliance ( NOx (15% O2) < 25 ppm; CO < 9 ppm), operation from 14% load to 100% load with low combustion dynamics and also to enable wide wobbe capability, which is a normalized measure of fuel flexibility.


Author(s):  
Jiao Liu ◽  
Jinfu Liu ◽  
Daren Yu ◽  
Zhongqi Wang ◽  
Weizhong Yan ◽  
...  

Failure of hot components in gas turbines often causes catastrophic results. Early fault detection can prevent serious incidents and improve the availability. A novel early fault detection method of hot components is proposed in this article. Exhaust gas temperature is usually used as the indicator to detect the fault in the hot components, which is measured by several exhaust thermocouples with uniform distribution at the turbine exhaust section. The healthy hot components cause uniform exhaust gas temperature (EGT) profile, whereas the hot component faults could cause the uneven EGT profile. However, the temperature differences between different thermocouple readings are also affected by different ambient and operating conditions, and it sometimes has a greater influence on EGT than the faults. In this article, an accurate EGT model is presented to eliminate the influence of different ambient and operating conditions on EGT. Especially, the EGT profile swirl under different ambient and operating conditions is also included by considering the information of the thermocouples’ spatial correlations and the EGT profile swirl angle. Based on the developed EGT model, the detection performance of early fault detection of hot components in gas turbine is improved. The accuracy and effectiveness of the developed early fault detection method are evaluated by the real-world gas turbine data.


Energies ◽  
2018 ◽  
Vol 11 (12) ◽  
pp. 3316 ◽  
Author(s):  
Qingcai Yang ◽  
Shuying Li ◽  
Yunpeng Cao ◽  
Fengshou Gu ◽  
Ann Smith

To ensure reliable and efficient operation of gas turbines, multiple model (MM) approaches have been extensively studied for online fault detection and isolation (FDI). However, current MM-FDI approaches are difficult to directly apply to gas path FDI, which is one of the common faults in gas turbines and is understood to mainly be due to the high complexity and computation in updating hypothetical gas path faults for online applications. In this paper, a fault contribution matrix (FCM) based MM-FDI approach is proposed to implement gas path FDI over a wide operating range. As the FCM is realized via an additive term of the healthy model set, the hypothetical models for various gas path faults can be easily established and updated online. In addition, a gap metric analysis method for operating points selection is also proposed, which yields the healthy model set from the equal intervals linearized models to approximate the nonlinearity of the gas turbine over a wide range of operating conditions with specified accuracy and computational efficiency. Simulation case studies conducted on a two-shaft marine gas turbine demonstrated the proposed approach is capable of adaptively updating hypothetical model sets to accurately differentiate both single and multiple faults of various gas path faults.


Author(s):  
Paul Pixner ◽  
Werner Krebs ◽  
Bernd Prade

One of the greatest challenges in modern gas turbine engineering is to optimize the combustion system for the reduction of emissions. For better understanding of combustion systems and hence having the possibility of systematic innovation of gas turbine combustion systems, a permanent improvement of design tools is essential. Demonstrated here is the use of an advanced combustion model — the INTRINSIC LOW DIMENSIONAL MANIFOLD (ILDM) approach — in Computational Flow Dynamics (CFD) analysis. In the past, chemical kinetic models used in CFD-calculations were based on empirical parameters and so called “global mechanisms” which are in fact “local” models and can be used only when modeling one operating point of the gas turbine combustion system. The scope of the integration of the ILDM approach into CFD is the use of a generalized approach for modeling chemical kinetics in CFD. Turbulence-chemistry interaction is considered by a presumed Probability Density Function (PDF) approach. The benefit of this method is a realistic prediction of all relevant flame characteristics e.g. piloting of premixed flames. This offers the possibility to integrate the whole combustion modeling tool in an overall emission prevention strategy. This work here will present the results of applying this new approach to an atmosperic test rig and first validation results.


Author(s):  
Sven Gunnar Sundkvist ◽  
Adrian Dahlquist ◽  
Jacek Janczewski ◽  
Mats Sjödin ◽  
Marie Bysveen ◽  
...  

A promising candidate for CO2 neutral power production is Semi-Closed Oxyfuel Combustion Combined Cycles (SCOC CC). Two alternative SCOC-CCs have been investigated both with recirculation of the Working Fluid (CO2 and H2O) but with different H2O content due to different conditions for condensation of water from the Working Fluid. The alternative with low moisture content in the re-circulated Working Fluid has shown highest thermodynamic potential and has been selected for further study. The necessity to use recirculated exhaust gas as the Working Fluid will make the design of the gas turbine quite different from a conventional gas turbine. For a combined cycle using a steam Rankine cycle as a bottoming cycle it is vital that the temperature of the exhaust gas from the Brayton cycle is well suited for steam generation that fits steam turbine live steam conditions. For oxyfuel gas turbines with a combustor outlet temperature of the same magnitude as conventional gas turbines a much higher pressure ratio is required (close to twice the ratio as for a conventional gas turbine) in order to achieve a turbine outlet temperature suitable for combined cycle. Based on input from the optimized cycle calculations a conceptual combustion system has been developed, where three different combustor feed streams can be controlled independently: the natural gas fuel, the oxidizer consisting mainly of oxygen plus some impurities, and the re-circulated Working Fluid. This gives more flexibility compared to air-based gas turbines, but introduces also some design challenges. A key issue is how to maintain high combustion efficiency over the entire load range using as little oxidizer as possible and with emissions (NOx, CO, UHC) within given constraints. Other important challenges are related to combustion stability, heat transfer and cooling, and material integrity, all of which are much affected when going from air-based to oxygen-based gas turbine combustion. Matching with existing air-based burner and combustor designs has been done in order to use as much as possible of what is proven technology today. The selected stabilization concept, heat transfer evaluation, burner and combustion chamber layout will be described. As a next step the pilot burner will be tested both at atmospheric and high pressure conditions.


Author(s):  
Uwe Krüger ◽  
Jens Hüren ◽  
Stefan Hoffmann ◽  
Werner Krebs ◽  
Patrick Flohr ◽  
...  

Environmental compatibility requires low emission burners for gas turbine power plants. In the past, significant progress has been made developing low NOx and CO burners by introducing lean premixed techniques in combination with annular combustion chambers. Unfortunately, these burners often have a more pronounced tendency to produce combustion-driven oscillations than conventional burner designs. The oscillations may be excited to such an extent that the risk of engine failure occurs. For this reason, the prediction of these thermoacoustic instabilities in the design phase of an engine becomes more and more important. A method based on linear acoustic four-pole elements has been developed to predict instabilities of the ring combustor of the 3A-series gas turbines (Krüger et al. (1999b)). The complex network includes the whole combustion system starting from both compressor outlet and fuel supply system and ending at the turbine inlet. The flame frequency response was determined by a transient numerical simulation (step-function approach). Based on this method, possible improvements for the gas turbine are evaluated in this paper. First, the burner impedance is predicted theoretically and compared with results from measurements on a test rig for validation of the prediction approach. Next, the burner impedance in a gas turbine combustion system is analyzed and improved thermoacoustically. Stability analyses for the gas turbine combustion system show the positive impact of this improvement. Second, the interaction of the acoustic parts of the gas turbine system has been detuned systematically in circumferential direction of the annular combustion chamber in order to find a more stable configuration. Stability analyses show the positive effect of this measure as well. The results predicted are compared with measurements from engine operation. The comparisons of prediction and measurements show the applicability of the prediction method in order to evaluate the thermoacoustic stability of the combustor as well as to define possible countermeasures.


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document