Tissue trauma and hemorrhagic shock are common battlefield injuries that can induce hypoxia, inflammation, and/or anemia. Inflammation and hypoxia can initiate adaptive mechanisms, such as stress erythropoiesis in the spleen, to produce red blood cells and restore the oxygen supply. In a military context, mild hypobaric hypoxia—part of the environmental milieu during aeromedical evacuation or en route care—may influence adaptive mechanisms, such as stress erythropoiesis, and host defense. In the present study, healthy (control), muscle trauma, and polytrauma (muscle trauma and hemorrhagic shock) mice were exposed to normobaric normoxia or hypobaric hypoxia for ∼17.5 h to test the hypothesis that hypobaric hypoxia exposure influences splenic erythropoiesis and splenic inflammation after polytrauma. This hypothesis was partially supported. The polytrauma + hypobaric hypoxia group exhibited more splenic neutrophils, fewer total spleen cells, and fewer splenic proliferating cells than the polytrauma+normobaric normoxia group; however, no splenic erythroid cell differences were detected between the two polytrauma groups. We also compared splenic erythropoiesis and myeloid cell numbers among control, muscle trauma, and polytrauma groups. More reticulocytes at 1.7 days (40 h) post-trauma (dpt) and neutrophils at 4 dpt were produced in the muscle trauma mice than corresponding control mice. In contrast to muscle trauma, polytrauma led to a reduced red blood cell count and elevated serum erythropoietin levels at 1.7 dpt. There were more erythroid subsets and apoptotic reticulocytes in the polytrauma mice than muscle trauma mice at 4 and 8 dpt. At 14 dpt, the red blood cell count of the polytrauma + normobaric normoxia mice was 12% lower than that of the control + normobaric normoxia mice; however, no difference was observed between polytrauma + hypobaric hypoxia and control + hypobaric hypoxia mice. Our findings suggest muscle trauma alone induces stress erythropoiesis; in a polytrauma model, hypobaric hypoxia exposure may result in the dysregulation of splenic cells, requiring a treatment plan to ensure adequate immune functioning.