We measured personal and altruistic fear of the police in a nationwide sample of Americans (N = 1,150), which included comparable numbers of Blacks (N = 517) and Whites (N = 492). Whites felt safe, but Blacks feared the police even more than crime, being afraid both for themselves and for others they cared about. The racial divide in fear was mediated by experiences with police mistreatment. In turn, fear mediated the effects of race and past mistreatment on support for defunding the police and intentions to have “the talk” with family youths about the need to distrust and avoid officers. About half of Blacks said they would rather be the victim of a serious crime than be questioned or searched by the police. The results show that when it comes to the police, Blacks and Whites live in different emotional worlds, one of fear and the other of felt safety.