Effect of a patent foramen ovale in humans on thermal responses to passive cooling and heating

Humans with a patent foramen ovale (PFO) have a higher esophageal temperature (Tesoph) than humans without a PFO (PFO−). Thus the presence of a PFO might also be associated with differences in thermal responsiveness to passive cooling and heating such as shivering and hyperpnea, respectively. The purpose of this study was to determine whether thermal responses to passive cooling and heating are different between PFO− subjects and subjects with a PFO (PFO+). We hypothesized that compared with PFO− subjects PFO+ subjects would cool down more rapidly and heat up slower and that PFO+ subjects who experienced thermal hyperpnea would have a blunted increase in ventilation. Twenty-seven men (13 PFO+) completed two trials separated by >48 h: 1) 60 min of cold water immersion (19.5 ± 0.9°C) and 2) 30 min of hot water immersion (40.5 ± 0.2°C). PFO+ subjects had a higher Tesoph before and during cold water and hot water immersion ( P < 0.05). However, the rate of temperature change was similar between groups for each condition. Within a subset of 18 subjects (8 PFO+) who experienced thermal hyperpnea, PFO+ subjects experienced thermal hyperpnea at a higher absolute Tesoph but with a blunted magnitude compared with PFO− subjects. These data suggest that PFO+ subjects have a higher Tesoph at rest and have blunted thermal hyperpnea during passive heating. NEW & NOTEWORTHY Patent foramen ovale (PFO) is found in ~25–40% of the population. The presence of a PFO appears to be associated with a greater core body temperature and blunted ventilatory responses during passive heating. The reason for this blunted ventilatory response to passive heating is unknown but may suggest differences in thermal sensitivity in PFO+ subjects compared with PFO− subjects.

Components and mechanisms of thermal hyperpnea

The pattern of breathing during a hyperthermia-induced hyperventilation varies across different species. Thermal tachypnea is a first phase panting response adopted during hyperthermia when tidal volume is minimized and the frequency of breathing is maximized. Blood-gas tensions and pH are maintained during this hyperventilation, and the associated heat loss helps the animal regulate its body temperature. A second pattern of breathing adopted in hyperthermia is thermal hyperpnea; this response is the focus of this review. This form of hyperventilation is evident after an increase in core temperature and it is apparent in humans. Increases of tidal volume as well as frequency of breathing are evident during this response that results in a respiratory alkalosis. The cause of thermal hyperpnea is not resolved; evidence of the potential mechanisms underlying this response support that modulators of the response act in either a multiplicative or additive manner with body temperatures. The details of the designs and methodologies of the studies supporting or refuting these two views are discussed. A physiological rationale for thermal hyperpnea is presented in which it is suggested this response serves a heat-loss role and contributes to selective brain cooling in hyperthermic humans. Ongoing research in this area is focused on resolving the mechanisms underlying thermal hyperpnea and its contribution to cranial thermoregulation. The direct application of this research is for the care of febrile and hyperthermic patients.