Physical and biological constraints on the capacity for life-history expression of anadromous salmonids: an Eel River, California, case study

Recovery of anadromous salmonid populations is complicated by their complex life-histories. We examined the spatiotemporal interplay of stream temperature, geomorphic features, and a species’ thermal sensitivity mediated by biological interactions in a case study of steelhead trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss) and Chinook salmon (O. tshawytscha) in California’s Eel River watershed. We estimated habitat suitability and fish capacity for each salmonid run and freshwater life stage during average, cool, and warm years in each of the watershed’s subbasins, including a historically-occupied high-elevation subbasin upstream of an impassable dam. Our estimates varied depending on whether we accounted for exposure to the Sacramento pikeminnow (Ptychocheilus grandis), an introduced predator/competitor. Our results indicate that the dammed subbasin has substantial salmonid capacity relative to the rest of the watershed and could provide an important cool-water refuge during warm years and from pikeminnow, potentially improving the productivity and resilience of multiple anadromous salmonid populations. Our approach can be applied in any setting where spatially explicit habitat metrics can be estimated and population specific and life-stage specific habitat criteria can be specified.

Sacramento Pikeminnow Migration Record

Sacramento Pikeminnow Ptychocheilus grandis is a potamodromous species endemic to mid- and low-elevation streams and rivers of Central and Northern California. Adults are known to undertake substantial migrations, typically associated with spawning, though few data exist on the extent of these migrations. Six Sacramento Pikeminnow implanted with passive integrated transponder tags in the Sacramento–San Joaquin Delta were detected in Cottonwood and Mill creeks, tributaries to the Sacramento River in Northern California, between April 2018 and late February 2020. Total travel distances ranged from 354 to 432 km, the maximum of which exceeds the previously known record by at least 30 km. These observations add to a limited body of knowledge regarding the natural history of Sacramento Pikeminnow and highlight the importance of the river–estuary continuum as essential for this migratory species.

Particle retention by non-suspension-feeding cyprinid fishes

Insectivorous Sacramento squawfish (Ptychocheilus grandis) and omnivorous benthic-feeding California roach (Hesperoleucus symmetricus) were exposed to suspended styrene microspheres (31-90 µm) or brine shrimp cysts (210-300 µm) in the presence of finely crushed Tetramin flakes or adult Artemia. These fish species retained small numbers of microspheres, and significantly more brine shrimp cysts than microspheres. During a 10-min period, they swallowed all of the brine shrimp cysts from a volume of water equivalent to 1-15 times their body volume. Squawfish and roach do not possess the morphological features of the branchial apparatus and palate that are associated with suspension feeding in confamilial Sacramento blackfish (Orthodon microlepidotus). The brine shrimp cysts could have been trapped between squawfish and roach gill rakers, while the microspheres as well as the brine shrimp cysts could have been retained on mucus-covered buccopharyngeal surfaces. These results suggest that non-suspension-feeding fish species may ingest small suspended particles routinely, with energetic and ecotoxicological implications that deserve further study.

Effect of predation by Sacramento squawfish (Ptychocheilus grandis) on habitat choice of California roach (Lavinia symmetricus) and rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss) in artificial streams

We studied the effects of predatory Sacramento squawfish (Ptychocheilus grandis) on habitat choice of juvenile California roach (Lavinia symmetricus), adult roach, and juvenile rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss) in artificial streams. In single-prey trials, the proportion of fish found in pool habitat declined in the presence of squawfish for juvenile roach (from 0.55 to 0.00), adult roach (from 0.88 to 0.13), and juvenile rainbow trout (0.70 to 0.15). The presence of squawfish did not affect the use of riffle and edge habitats. Of the fish found in shallow water, the proportion found in edge habitat declined from juvenile roach (0.95) to adult roach (0.80) to juvenile rainbow trout (0.23). We also conducted experiments designed to simulate invasion of an area by squawfish, in which adult roach and juvenile rainbow trout were tested together in the presence and absence of squawfish. The proportion of prey in pool habitat in the presence of squawfish was greater in the two-prey trials than in the single-prey trials for both adult roach (0.31 and 0.13, respectively) and juvenile rainbow trout (0.33 and 0.15, respectively). These results support field evidence that squawfish are an important force in determining the spatial structure of native stream fish assemblages.

Changes in Habitat and Microhabitat Partitioning within an Assemblage of Stream Fishes in Response to Predation by Sacramento Squawfish (Ptychocheilus grandis)

The Sacramento squawfish (Ptychocheilus grandis), a piscivorous cyprinid, was recently (ca. 1979) introduced into the Eel River, California, USA. We compared habitat and microhabitat use of resident fishes between areas where squawfish were present and absent at one location and between years before and after invasion by squawfish at a second location. The resident species showed a variety of responses to the presence of the predator. Juvenile rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss) and juvenile Sacramento suckers (Catostomus occidentalis) increased their use of fast-flowing riffles at both locations, in the presence of squawfish. Suckers also used significantly shallower depths within habitat types. Adult California roach (Lavinia symmetricus) decreased their use of run habitat and increased use of pools and riffles at the first site, but not at the second. When squawfish were present, juvenile roach and threespine stickleback (Casterosteus aculeatus) were found in shallower water closer to the stream edge in all habitats. Spatial overlaps tended to be lower in the presence of squawfish. The introduction of squawfish has resulted in changes in the habitat and microhabitat use of the resident fish assemblage but no loss of species.