The Effect of Tip Shroud Geometries on Last Turbine Stage Efficiency

Last stages of steam turbines and heavy-duty power gas turbines contribute significantly to output power and efficiency of whole turbine. Moreover, radial distribution of parameters downstream of the last stage provides boundary conditions for diffuser design. Thus, the increase of the last stage efficiency and obtainment of favorable radial distribution downstream of the last rotor blade is very important. Due to the long blades of last stages, resonance might occur. To avoid dangerous frequencies a damping wire or damping bolts are used. Such damping elements result in additional losses, so to minimize these losses a damping shroud is used instead. In general, the full damping shroud has to provide both the aerodynamic loss reduction and the resonance frequency offset. However, in most cases due to mechanical integrity limits instead of the full shroud a partial shroud is used. In this case the loss reduction feature of the partial shroud is diminished as compared with the full shroud. Sometimes, the use of the partial shroud results in the decrease of the efficiency compared with a stage with unshrouded rotor blades at small tip clearances. In this paper, a numerical investigation of the flow structure around full and partial shrouds with various geometries as well as the effect of the various shroud geometries on the turbine stage efficiency is carried out. Eight geometries with different number of fins of various heights are studied. Moreover, stage efficiencies for both shrouded and unshrouded blade are compared. Based on this comparison, reasonable design recommendations aimed to reduce the losses within the radial gap over the shroud are developed. In particular, filling the space in the gap with the additional honeycombs is considered and the effect on the flow structure and the last stage efficiency investigated. Numerical results obtained in the paper correspond well to the published test data.

Aerodynamic Optimization of a Winglet-Shroud Tip Geometry for a Linear Turbine Cascade

This paper presents a continued study on a previously investigated novel winglet-shroud (WS) (or partial shroud) geometry for a linear turbine cascade. Various widths of double-side winglets (DSW) and different locations of a partial shroud are considered. In addition, both a plain tip and a full shroud tip are applied as the datum cases which were examined experimentally and numerically. Total pressure loss and viscous loss coefficients are comparatively employed to execute a quantitative analysis of aerodynamic performance. The effectiveness of various widths (w) of DSW set at 3%, 5%, 7%, and 9% of the blade pitch (p) is numerically investigated. Skin-friction lines on the tip surface indicate that different DSW cases do not alter flow field features including the separation bubble and reattachment flow within the tip gap region, even for the case with the broadest width (w/p = 9%). However, the pressure side extension of the DSW exhibits the formation of separation bubble, while the suction side platform of the DSW turns the tip leakage vortex (TLV) away from the suction surface (SS). Meanwhile, the horse-shoe vortex (HV) near the casing is not generated even for the case with the smallest width (w/p = 3%). As a result, both the tip leakage and the upper passage vortices are weakened and further dissipated with wider w/p in the DSW cases. Larger width of the DSW geometry is indeed able to improve the aerodynamic performance, but only to a slight degree. With the w/p increasing from 3% to 9%, the mass-averaged total pressure loss coefficient over an exit plane is reduced by only 2.61%. Therefore, considering both the enlarged (or reduced) tip area and the enhanced (or deteriorated) performance compared to the datum cases, a favorable width of w/p = 5% is chosen to design the WS structure. Three locations for the partial shroud (linkage segment) are devised, locating them near the leading edge, in the middle and close to the trailing edge, respectively. Results demonstrate that all three cases of the WS design have advantages over the DSW arrangement in lessening the aerodynamic loss, with the middle linkage segment location producing the optimal effect. This conclusion verifies the feasibility of the previously studied WS configuration.

Aerodynamic Optimization of a Winglet-Shroud Tip Geometry for a Linear Turbine Cascade

This paper presents a continued study on a previously investigated novel winglet-shroud (WS) (or partial shroud) geometry for a linear turbine cascade. Various width of double-side winglets and different locations of a partial shroud are considered. In addition, both a plain tip and a full shroud tip are applied as the datum cases which were examined experimentally and numerically. Total pressure loss and viscous loss coefficients are comparatively employed to execute a quantitative analysis of the aerodynamic performance. The effectiveness of various width (w) of double-side winglets (DSW) involving 3%, 5%, 7% and 9% of the blade pitch (p) is numerically investigated. Skin-friction lines on the tip surface indicate that the different DSW cases do not alter flow field features including the separation bubble and reattachment flow within the tip gap region, even for the case with the broadest width (w/p = 9%). However, the pressure side extension of the DSW exhibits the formation of the separation bubble, while the suction side platform of the DSW turns the tip leakage vortex away from the suction surface. Meanwhile, the horse-shoe vortex near the casing is not generated even for the case with the smallest width (w/p=3%). As a result, both the tip leakage and the upper passage vortices are weakened and further dissipated with wider w/p in the DSW cases. Larger width of the DSW geometry is indeed able to improve the aerodynamic performance, but in a slight degree. With the w/p increasing from 3% to 9%, the mass-averaged total pressure loss coefficient over an exit plane is just reduced by 2.61%. Therefore, considering both the enlarged (or reduced) tip area and the enhanced (or deteriorated) performance compared to the datum cases, a favorable width of w/p=5% is chosen to design the WS structure. Three locations of the partial shroud (linkage segment) are devised, which are located near the leading edge, the middle and close to the trailing edge respectively. Results illustrates that all three cases of the WS have advantages in lessening the aerodynamic loss over the DSW arrangement, but with the linkage segment located in the middle having optimal effect. This conclusion verifies the feasibility of the previously studied WS configuration.

Numerical and Experimental Investigation of Aerodynamic Performance for a Straight Turbine Cascade With a Novel Partial Shroud

A comparative experimental and numerical analysis is carried out to assess the aerodynamic performance of a novel partial shroud in a straight turbine cascade. This partial shroud is designed as a combination of winglet and shroud. A plain tip is employed as a baseline case. A pure winglet tip is also studied for comparison. Both experiments and predictions demonstrate that this novel partial shroud configuration has aerodynamic advantages over the pure winglet arrangement. Predicted results show that, relative to the baseline blade with a plain tip, using the partial shroud can lead to a reduction of 20.89% in the mass-averaged total pressure coefficient on the upper half-span of a plane downstream of the cascade trailing edge and 16.53% in the tip leakage mass flow rate, whereas the pure winglet only decreases these two performance parameters by 11.36% and 1.32%, respectively. The flow physics is explored in detail to explain these results via topological analyses. The use of this new partial shroud significantly affects the topological structures and total pressure loss coefficients on various axial cross sections, particularly at the rear part of the blade passage. The partial shroud not only weakens the tip leakage vortex (TLV) but also reduces the strength of passage vortex near the casing (PVC) endwall. Furthermore, three partial shrouds with width-to-pitch ratios of 3%, 5%, and 7% are considered. With an increase in the width of the winglet part, improvements in aerodynamics and the tip leakage mass flow rate are limited.

Performance Improvement of a Centrifugal Compressor by Passive Means

The present experimental investigation deals with performance improvement of a low-speed centrifugal compressor by inexpensive passive means such as turbulence generator placed at different positions and partial shroud near the rotor blade tip. The experiments are carried out at three values of tip clearance, namely 2.2%, 5.1%, and 7.9% of rotor blade height at the exit. Performance tests are carried out for a total of 13 configurations. From these measurements, partial shroud is found to give the best performance. The improvement in the compressor performance may be due to the reduction of tip leakage flows by the small extension of partial shroud (2 mm on the pressure surface side). Although there is nominal change in performance due to turbulence generator (TG), TG has beneficial effect of increased operating range.

Effect of Partial Shrouds on the Performance and Flow Field of a Low-Aspect-Ratio Axial-Flow Fan Rotor

The flow field at the rotor exit of a low aspect ratio axial flow fan for different tip geometries and for different flow coefficients is measured in the present study. The following configurations are tested: (1) rotor without partial shroud, designated as rotor (wos), (2) rotor with partial shroud, designated as rotor (ws), and (3) rotor with perforated (perforations in the shape of discrete circular holes) partial shroud, designated as rotor (wps). From steady state measurements, the performance of rotor (wps) is found to be the best. Both the rotors with partial shrouds have stalled at a higher flow coefficient compared to that of rotor (wos). From periodic flow measurements, it is concluded that the low velocity region near the tip section is considerably reduced with the use of partial shrouds with perforations. The extent of this low velocity region for both rotor (wos) and rotor (wps) increases with decreasing flow coefficient due to increased stage loading. This core of low momentum fluid has moved inwards of the annulus and towards the pressure side as the flow coefficient decreases. The extent of the low momentum fluid is smaller for rotor (wps) than that of rotor (wos) at all flow coefficients.

Optimized Shroud Design for Axial Turbine Aerodynamic Performance

This paper presents a comprehensive study of the effect of shroud design in axial turbine aerodynamics. Experimental measurements and numerical simulations have been conducted on three different test cases with identical blade geometry and tip clearances but different shroud designs. The first and second test cases are representative of a full shroud and a nonaxisymmetric partial shroud geometry while the third test case uses an optimized partial shroud. Partial shrouds are sometimes used in industrial application in order to benefit from the advantage of shrouded configuration, as well as reduce mechanical stress on the blades. However, the optimal compromise between mechanical considerations and aerodynamic performances is still an open issue due to the resulting highly three-dimensional unsteady flow field. Aerodynamic performance is measured in a low-speed axial turbine facility and shows that there are clear differences between the test cases. In addition, steady and time resolved measurements are performed together with computational analysis in order to improve the understanding of the effect of the shroud geometry on the flow field and to quantify the sources of the resultant additional losses. The flow field analysis shows that the effect of the shroud geometry is significant from 60% blade height span to the tip. Tip leakage vortex in the first rotor is originated in the partial shroud test cases while the full shroud case presents only a weak indigenous tip passage vortex. This results in a significant difference in the secondary flow development in the following second stator with associated losses that varies by about 1% in this row. The analysis shows that the modified partial shroud design has improved considerably the aerodynamic efficiency by about 0.6% by keeping almost unchanged the overall weight of this component, and thus blade root stresses. The work, therefore, presents a comprehensive flow field analysis and shows the impact of the shroud geometry in the aerodynamic performance.

Optimized Shroud Design for Axial Turbine Aerodynamic Performance

This paper presents a comprehensive study of the effect of shroud design in axial turbine aerodynamics. Experimental measurements and numerical simulations has been conducted on three different test cases with identical blade geometry and tip clearances but different shroud designs. The first and the second test cases are representative of a full shroud and a non-axisymmetric partial shroud geometry while the third test case however uses an optimized partial shroud. Partial shrouds are sometimes used in industrial application in order to benefit from the advantage of shrouded configuration as well as reducing mechanical stress on the blades. However, the optimal compromise between mechanical considerations and aerodynamic performances is still an open issue due to the resulting highly 3-dimensional unsteady flow field. Aerodynamic performance is measured in a low-speed axial turbine facility and shows that there are clear differences between the test cases. In addition, steady and time resolved measurements are performed together with computational analysis in order to improve understanding of the effect of the shroud geometry on the flow field and to quantify the sources of the resultant additional losses. The flow field analysis shows that the effect of the shroud geometry is significant from 60% blade height span to the tip. Tip leakage vortex in the first rotor is originated in the partial shroud test cases while the full shroud case present only a weak indigenous tip passage vortex. This results in a significant difference in the secondary flow development in the following second stator with associated losses that varies of about 1% in this row. The analysis shows that the modified partial shroud design has improved considerably the aerodynamic efficiency of about 0.6% by keeping almost unchanged the overall weight of this component and thus blade root stresses. The work therefore presents a comprehensive flow field analysis and the shows the impact of the shroud geometry in the aerodynamic performance.

Fluid Dynamics and Performance of Partially and Fully Shrouded Axial Turbines

A unique comparative experimental and numerical investigation carried out on two test cases with shroud configurations, differing only in the labyrinth seal path, is presented in this paper. The blade geometry and tip clearance are identical in the two test cases. The geometries under investigation are representative of an axial turbine with a full and partial shroud, respectively. Global performance and flow field data were acquired and analyzed. Computational simulations were carried out to complement the investigation and to facilitate the analysis of the steady and unsteady flow measurements. A detailed comparison between the two test cases is presented in terms of flow field analysis and performance evaluation. The analysis focuses on the flow effects reflected on the overall performance in a multi-stage environment. Strong interaction between the cavity flow and the blade tip region of the rotor blades is observed up to the blade midspan. A marked effect of this interaction can be seen in the downstream second stator where different vortex structures are observed. Moreover, in the partial shroud test case, a strong tip leakage vortex is developed from the first rotor and transported through the downstream blade row. A measurable change in the second stage efficiency was observed between the two test cases. In low aspect ratio blades within a multi-stage environment, small changes in the cavity geometry can have a significant effect on the mainstream flow. The present analysis has shown that an integrated and matched blade-shroud aerodynamic design has to be adopted to reach optimal performances. The additional losses resulting from small variations of the sealing geometry could result in a gain of up to one point in the overall stage efficiency.

Fluid Dynamics and Performance of Partially and Fully Shrouded Axial Turbines

A unique comparative experimental and numerical investigation carried out on two test cases with shroud configurations differing only in the labyrinth seal path, is presented in this paper. The blade geometry and tip clearance is identical in the two test cases. The geometries under investigation are representative of an axial turbine with a full and partial shroud, respectively. Global performance and flow field data were acquired and analyzed. Computational simulations were carried out to complement the investigation and to facilitate the analysis of the steady and unsteady flow measurements. A detailed comparison between the two test cases is presented in terms of flow field analysis and performance evaluation. The analysis focuses on the flow effects reflected on the overall performance in a multi-stage environment. Strong interaction between the cavity flow and the blade tip region of the rotor blades is observed up to the blade mid span. A marked effect of this interaction can be seen in the downstream second stator where different vortex structures are observed. Moreover, in the partial shroud test case, a strong tip leakage vortex is developed from the first rotor and transported through the downstream blade row. A measurable change in the second stage efficiency was observed between the two test cases. In low aspect ratio blades within a multistage environment, small changes in the cavity geometry can have a significant effect on the mainstream flow. The present analysis has shown that an integrated and matched blade-shroud aerodynamic design has to be adopted to reach optimal performances. The additional losses resulting from small variations of the sealing geometry could result in a gain of up to one point in the overall stage efficiency.