An Investigation of Rotating Stall and Surge of a 10-Stage Subsonic Compressor

Author(s):  
Xie Jinan ◽  
Bai Xiaoxu

This article covers the analysis and study of the surge characteristic in a full-scale 10-stage subsonic compressor under the condition of performance test. The transient responses which arised after the compressor enters in non-stationary condition range are estimated through an improved nonlinear calculation model. There are two different kinds of response (or transient processe) model: stall pattern and surge pattern. The calculated results coincide with the test very well. When relative turning speed ñ ≤ 0.5, the system transient process is shown in stall pattern; when ñ ≥ 0.6, it is surge pattern. The obtainted calculation result has been drawn as a system transient process locus in the nondimensional flow-pressure rise phase plane. The nondimensional parameters affecting system transient process pattern were analysed and compared with the results made by E.M. Greitzer.

1992 ◽  
Author(s):  
Hu Jun ◽  
Tang Guo Cai ◽  
Zhang Hui Min

Using the theory developed by Moore and Greitzer, a simplified approximate method is proposed to calculate the evolution of the mass flow, pressure rise, and the growth and decay of rotating stall cell during post stall transients or recovery process in multistage arial compression systems. The method leads to a set of three simultaneous nonlinear first order partial differential equations, and for the numerical solution, a simple explicit time marching method can be used. It is shewa that a study of rotating-statt-like and surge-like motion, recoverability from rotating stall or surge, and limited parameters can be carried out through this method. It has been found that, except the two general types of distinct flow instabilities (rotating stall and surge), there is another type of instability in arial compression systems, which has the basic characteristic of both rotating stall and surge. Some qualitative comparisons with available experimental results and some qualitative comparisons with test data are made in this paper. It shows that the proposed model is very simple, accurate and dependable.


1986 ◽  
Vol 108 (2) ◽  
pp. 231-239 ◽  
Author(s):  
E. M. Greitzer ◽  
F. K. Moore

Using the theory developed in Part I, calculations have been carried out to show the evolution of the mass flow, pressure rise, and rotating-stall cell amplitude during compression system post-stall transients. In particular, it is shown that the unsteady growth or decay of the stall cell can have a significant effect on the instantaneous compressor pumping characteristic and hence on the overall system behavior. A limited parametric study is carried out to illustrate the impact of different system features on transient behavior. It is shown, for example, that the ultimate mode of system response, surge or stable rotating stall, depends not only on the B parameter, but also on the compressor length-to-radius ratio. Small values of the latter quantity tend to favor the occurrence of surge, as do large values of B. Based on the analytical and numerical results, some specific topics are suggested for future research on post-stall transients.


Author(s):  
Robert J. McKee ◽  
Justin R. Hollingsworth ◽  
Anthony J. Smalley

As gas pipeline and industrial compressors become more powerful and more complex, it has become beneficial to conduct technical audits of these machines in the design stage. Detailed analysis of critical or advanced compressors by independent evaluators have identified operating limitations, resonant responses, potential vibrations, weak components, the onset of stall, and other instabilities, and have recommended ways to eliminate a variety of potential problems before the compressor is placed in operation. The suitability of a compressor and its driver for the planned service should be thoroughly evaluated, so that each component and the system not only satisfy the design conditions, but also extreme operating conditions. This paper presents a description of the tools available for design audits and gives examples of benefits that have resulted from recent audits. The rotordynamics of any large high-speed compressor should be carefully evaluated to identify potential instabilities, high vibration levels, and even destructive responses of the machine. Powerful rotordynamic analysis tools and specific knowledge exists to accurately predict bearing and seal stiffness and damping, lateral critical speeds, and damped forced responses. Some examples of significant results obtained from rotordynamic evaluations are presented, and typical problems that have been identified and eliminated are highlighted. Torsional vibration analyses for compressor trains are an essential aspect of a design audit that have identified vibration problems and weak components. Examples of torsional vibration responses and problems that can be identified and corrected are included in this paper. The aerodynamics of a compressor is a design audit topic to which attention should be paid. Thermophysical properties of the process gas, as it is compressed, are important quantities which can be accurately determined by modern equations of state. The internal velocity distribution and pressure rise per impeller and diffuser can be evaluated to identify areas of excess loss, poor work transfer, or restrictions within a compressor. Flow angles such as at the impeller and diffuser entrances can be predicted and evaluated. The diffuser inlet flow angle is a critical indicator of the onset of rotating stall. This type of aerodynamic analysis also provides important input for performance test planning and evaluation. This paper concludes with a summary of benefits of design audits for pipeline and industrial compressors.


Author(s):  
Wangzhi Zou ◽  
Xiao He ◽  
Wenchao Zhang ◽  
Zitian Niu ◽  
Xinqian Zheng

The stability considerations of centrifugal compressors become increasingly severe with the high pressure ratios, especially in aero-engines. Diffuser is the major subcomponent of centrifugal compressor, and its performance greatly influences the stability of compressor. This paper experimentally investigates the roles of vanes in diffuser on component instability and compression system instability. High pressure ratio centrifugal compressors with and without vanes in diffuser are tested and analyzed. Rig tests are carried out to obtain the compressor performance map. Dynamic pressure measurements and relevant Fourier analysis are performed to identify complex instability phenomena in the time domain and frequency domain, including rotating instability, stall, and surge. For component instability, vanes in diffuser are capable of suppressing the emergence of rotating stall in the diffuser at full speeds, but barely affect the characteristics of rotating instability in the impeller at low and middle speeds. For compression system instability, it is shown that the use of vanes in diffuser can effectively postpone the occurrence of compression system surge at full speeds. According to the experimental results and the one-dimensional flow theory, vanes in diffuser turn the diffuser pressure rise slope more negative and thus improve the stability of compressor stage, which means lower surge mass flow rate.


Author(s):  
Xi Nan ◽  
Feng Lin ◽  
Takehiro Himeno ◽  
Toshinori Watanabe

Casing boundary layer effectively places a limit on the pressure rise capability achievable by the compressor. The separation of the casing boundary layer not only produce flow loss but also closely related to the compressor rotating stall. The motivation of this paper is to present a viewpoint that the casing boundary layer should be paid attention to in parallel with other flow factors on rotating stall trigger. This paper illustrates the casing boundary layer behavior by displaying its separation phenomena with the presence of tip leakage vortex at different flow conditions. Skin friction lines and the corresponding absolute streamlines are used to demonstrate the three-dimensional flow patterns on and near the casing. The results depict a Saddle, a Node and several tufts of skin friction lines dividing the passage into four zones. The tip leakage vortex is enfolded within one of the zones by the separated flows. All the flows in each blade passage are confined within the passage as long as the compressor is stable. The casing boundary layer of a transonic compressor is also examined in the same way, which results in qualitatively similar zonal flows that enfolds the tip leakage vortex. This research develops a new way to study the casing boundary layer in rotating compressors. The results may provide a first-principle based explanation to stalling mechanisms for compressors that are casing sensitive.


Author(s):  
Jiaguo Hu ◽  
Tianyu Pan ◽  
Wenqian Wu ◽  
Qiushi Li ◽  
Yifang Gong

The instability has been the largest barrier of the high performance axial compressor in the past decades. Stall inception, which determines the route and the characteristics of instability evolution, has been extensively focused on. A new stall inception, “partial surge”, is discovered in the recent experiments. In this paper full-annulus transient simulations are performed to study the origin of partial surge initiated inception and explain the aerodynamic mechanism. The simulations show that the stall inception firstly occurs at the stator hub region, and then transfers to the rotor tip region. The compressor finally stalled by the tip region rotating stall. The stall evolution is in accord with the experiments. The stall evolution can be divided into three phases. In the first phase, the stator corner separation gradually merged with the adjacent passages, producing an annulus stall cell at the stator hub region. In the second phase, the total pressure rise of hub region emerges rapid decline due to the fast expansion of the annulus stall cell, but the tip region maintains its pressure rise. In the third phase, a new rotating stall cell appears at the rotor tip region, leading to the onset of fast drop of the tip region pressure rise. The stall cells transfer from hub region to the tip region is caused by two factors, the blockage of the hub region which transfers more load to the tip region, and the separation fluid fluctuations in stator domain which increase the circumferential non-uniformity in the rotor domain. High load and non-uniformity at the rotor tip region induce the final rotating stall.


Author(s):  
Steven P. Nuspl ◽  
Philip M. Gerhart

The ASME Performance Test Code, PTC 11 Fans, is currently undergoing revision. While there are several changes being made, there are also new additions, the most notable of which is a method to measure input power at reduced fan loads. This information is often required to validate a power guarantee; a condition that presents a unique challenge because fan operation needs to be established at a specific flow and pressure rise that can be corrected to guarantee inlet conditions using the fan laws of similarity. Part 1 of this paper outlines a testing procedure to achieve results close to the specified condition. There is a very low probability that any particular test can be performed at the guarantee condition so several tests within acceptable bounds of the specified point are necessary. Part 2 of this paper discusses a multipoint, distance-weighted interpolation method for determining the final result.


2001 ◽  
Vol 90 (6) ◽  
pp. 2238-2244 ◽  
Author(s):  
Stephanie A. Eucker ◽  
Jennifer B. Lisauskas ◽  
Jasvindar Singh ◽  
Sándor J. Kovács

We sought to extract additional physiological information from the time-dependent left ventricular (LV) pressure contour and thereby gain new insights into ventricular function. We used phase plane analysis to characterize high-fidelity pressure data in selected subjects undergoing elective cardiac catheterization. The standard hemodynamic indexes of LV systolic and diastolic function derived from the time-dependent LV pressure contour could be easily obtained using the phase plane method. Additional novel attributes of the phase plane pressure loop, such as phase plane pressure loop area, graphical representation of the isovolumic relaxation time constant, and quantitative measures of beat-to-beat systolic-diastolic coupling were characterized. The asymmetry between the pressures at which maximum isovolumic pressure rise and pressure fall occur, as well as their load dependence, were also easily quantitated. These results indicate that the phase plane method provides a novel window for physiological discovery and has theoretical and applied advantages in quantitative ventricular function characterization.


Author(s):  
Mohammad Javad Shahriyari ◽  
Hossein Khaleghi ◽  
Martin Heinrich

This paper reports on a theory for poststall transients in contra-rotating fans, which is developed from the basic Moore–Greitzer theory. A second-order hysteresis term is assumed for the fan pressure rise, which gives the theory more capabilities in predicting the fan instabilities. The effect of the rotational speed ratio of the two counter rotating rotors on the fan performance during the occurrence of surge and rotating stall are studied (the rotational speed of the front rotor is assumed to be kept constant whereas the speed of the rear rotor is variable). One of the new capabilities of the current model is the possibility of investigating the effect of the initial slope on the fan characteristic. Results reveal that unlike the conventional fans and compressors, in the current contra-rotating fan stall cannot be initiated from the negative slope portion of the fan pressure rise characteristic curve. One of the important advantages of the developed model is that it enables investigation of the effect of the rate of throttling on the instabilities. Results show that more the rotational speed of the rear rotor, the more robust to surge (caused by throttling) the fan is.


Author(s):  
N. Gourdain ◽  
S. Burguburu ◽  
G. J. Michon ◽  
N. Ouayahya ◽  
F. Leboeuf ◽  
...  

This paper deals with the first instability which occurs in compressors, close to the maximum of pressure rise, called rotating stall. A numerical simulation of these flow phenomena is performed and a comparison with experimental data is made. The configuration used for the simulation is an axial single-stage and low speed compressor (compressor CME2, LEMFI). The whole stage is modeled with a full 3D approach and tip clearance is taken into account. The numerical simulation shows that at least two different mechanisms are involved in the stall inception. The first one leads to a rotating stall with 10 cells and the second one leads to a configuration with only 3 cells. Unsteady signals from the computation are analyzed thanks to a time-frequency spectral analysis. An original model is proposed, in order to predict the spatial and the temporal modes which are the results of the interaction between stall cells and the compressor stage. A comparison with measurements shows that the computed stall inception point corresponds to the experimental limit of stability. The performance of the compressor during rotating stall is also well predicted by the simulation.


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document