Turn-Down Capability of Ansaldo Energia’s GT26

2021 ◽  
Author(s):  
Ralf Jakoby ◽  
Jörg Rinn ◽  
Christoph Appel ◽  
Adrien Studerus

Abstract The operational flexibility of heavy-duty gas turbines is of increasing importance in today’s power generation market. Fast start-up, fast loading, grid frequency support, fuel flexibility and turn-down capability are only some of the keywords that describe the challenges for GT manufacturers. This paper reports Ansaldo Energia’s activities to further reduce the Minimum Environmental Load (MEL) of the GT26. The difficulties related to operation at very low loads and the solutions that were developed are explained. Furthermore, the results of engine validation tests of the new extended Low Load Operation (eLLO) and extended Low Part Load (eLPL) operation concepts are presented. The enhancement of the operational flexibility of the GT26 is in the focus of Ansaldo’s development activities since many years. Its sequential combustion system is a very good basis for flexible and emission compliant operation down to very low loads. Ansaldo Energia’s Low Part Load (LPL) and Low Load Operation (LLO) concepts are standard products in the GT26 flexibility portfolio and established in the market for many years. Low Part Load (LPL) operation extends the standard operating range down to low loads by switching off individual burners in the second combustor (SEV combustor). The compressor mass flow can be varied between idle and base load levels. Low Load Operation is characterized by a combination of idle compressor mass flow and base load temperatures in the first Combustor (EV combustor). The SEV combustor is switched off. LLO is intended to be a “parking point”, where the plant can operate in combined cycle mode during times of low electricity demand. Ansaldo Energia has conducted a development project in the past two years in order to further reduce the minimum simple cycle and combined cycle loads. The extension of the LLO and LPL operating ranges and their combination into one single feature are the main targets of the project.

Author(s):  
Ralf Jakoby ◽  
Jörg Rinn ◽  
Christoph Appel ◽  
Adrien Studerus

Abstract The operational flexibility of heavy-duty gas turbines is of increasing importance in today's power generation market. Fast start-up, fast loading, grid frequency support, fuel flexibility and turn-down capability are only some of the keywords that describe the challenges for GT manufacturers. This paper reports Ansaldo Energia's activities to further reduce the Minimum Environmental Load (MEL) of the GT26. The difficulties related to operation at very low loads and the solutions that were developed are explained. Furthermore, the results of engine validation tests of the new extended Low Load Operation (eLLO) and extended Low Part Load (eLPL) operation concepts are presented. The enhancement of the operational flexibility of the GT26 is in the focus of Ansaldo's development activities since many years. Its sequential combustion system is a very good basis for flexible and emission compliant operation down to very low loads. Ansaldo Energia's Low Part Load (LPL) and Low Load Operation (LLO) concepts are standard products in the GT26 flexibility portfolio and established in the market for many years. Ansaldo Energia has conducted a development project in the past two years in order to further reduce the minimum simple cycle and combined cycle loads. The extension of the LLO and LPL operating ranges and their combination into one single feature are the main targets of the project.


Author(s):  
Vladimir Vassiliev ◽  
Thomas P. Sommer ◽  
Andrei Granovsky ◽  
Sergey Prozorov

In todays electricity market with a strong mix of renewables and traditional energy sources, heavy-duty gas turbines often have to operate at part load with decreased exhaust mass flow. Decreased mass flow leads to reduced Mach number and this factor drives the exhaust loss down. At the same time off-design conditions lead to reduction of diffuser pressure recovery, and this factor drives loss up. The latter is normally stronger, and therefore the losses at GT low load are higher than at base load. Traditionally exhaust diffusers were optimised for base load operation, and their characteristics were analysed in range close to this regime. However with increased part load operation it became important to investigate strong off-design conditions as well. In this work the numerical analysis of diffuser flow at different conditions corresponding to GT base load and different part loads is performed. In the first part of the paper the numerical model and results of calculations are discussed. The calculations are compared with measurements in real engine, and this comparison demonstrates that numerical model provides good predictions not only for design conditions, but for off-design conditions as well. The validated numerical model was then applied to analysis of diffuser geometry impact on the off design conditions, and the second part of the paper describes the results of these calculations. The analysis showed that modification of central body and front part of diffuser have negligible impact on losses at off design conditions, but significantly reduce performance at base load leading to non-optimal redistribution of losses between different regimes. Therefore original diffuser configuration provides the best compromise for wide operational window.


2018 ◽  
Vol 141 (1) ◽  
Author(s):  
Max H. Baumgärtner ◽  
Thomas Sattelmayer

Volatile renewable energy sources induce power supply fluctuations. These need to be compensated by flexible conventional power plants. Gas turbines in combined cycle power plants adjust the power output quickly but their turn-down ratio is limited by the slow reaction kinetics, which leads to CO and unburned hydrocarbon emissions. To extend the turn-down ratio, part of the fuel can be converted to syngas, which exhibits a higher reactivity. By an increasing fraction of syngas in the fuel, the reactivity of the mixture is increased and total fuel mass flow and the power output can be reduced. An autothermal on-board syngas generator in combination with two different burner concepts for natural gas (NG)/syngas mixtures was presented in a previous study (Baumgärtner, M. H., and Sattelmayer, T., 2017, “Low Load Operation Range Extension by Autothermal On-Board Syngas Generation,” ASME J. Eng. Gas Turbines Power, 140(4), p. 041505). The study at hand shows a mass-flow variation of the reforming process with mass flows, which allow for pure syngas combustion and further improvements of the two burner concepts which result in a more application-oriented operation. The first of the two burner concepts comprises a generic swirl stage with a central lance for syngas injection. Syngas is injected with swirl to avoid a negative impact on the total swirl intensity and nonswirled. The second concept includes a central swirl stage with an outer ring of jets. For this burner, syngas is injected in both stages to avoid NOx emissions from the swirl stage. Increased NOx emissions produced by NG combustion of the swirl pilot were reported in last year's paper. For both burners, combustion performance is analyzed by OH*-chemiluminescence and gaseous emissions. The lowest possible adiabatic flame temperature without a significant increase of CO emissions was 170–210 K lower for the syngas compared to low load pure NG combustion. This corresponds to a decrease of 15–20% in terms of thermal power.


Author(s):  
Pratyush Nag ◽  
David Little ◽  
Adam Plant ◽  
Douglas Roth

The US gas turbine (GT) power generation market has seen significant volatility in recent years due to climate changes, changes in natural gas prices and the uncertain future of nuclear and coal power generation. Many gas turbine power plants originally intended to operate on a more continuous basis (base load) are operating in intermittent dispatch mode which has caused some operators to frequently shut down their units. This frequent cycling of units can increase start-up and maintenance costs. It could be beneficial to these plants to operate at lower loads when power demand is low and ramp up to higher loads as demand increases. A key issue in operating at lower loads is an increase in carbon monoxide (CO) emissions. When the engines are base loaded, the combustion system operates at high firing temperatures and most of the CO is oxidized to carbon dioxide (CO2). However, at part loads — when the firing temperature is lower — the CO to CO2 oxidation reaction is quenched by the cool regions near the walls of the combustion liner. This results in increased CO emissions at low loads. In order to provide greater operational flexibility to its F- & G-class gas turbine operators, Siemens has developed an upgrade for the engine system designed to allow the gas turbine to operate at lower loads while maintaining emissions. This low load turndown upgrade has been installed, tested and is currently in operation at 8 F and 4 G class Siemens operating gas turbines. These plants were previously operating typically between 70% and 100% of GT base load. Sometimes, when the demand for power was low, typically at night and on weekends, these plants would shut down. During these low power demand periods — with this upgrade installed — these plants continue to operate down to lower loads while maintaining CO emissions and with a capability to more quickly ramp-up to full load when the demand for power increases. This paper details the installation, testing results and continued validation of the Low Load Turndown upgrade.


Author(s):  
William D. York ◽  
Derrick W. Simons ◽  
Yongqiang Fu

F-class gas turbines comprise a major part of the heavy-duty gas turbine power generation fleet worldwide, despite increasing penetration of H/J class turbines. F-class gas turbines see a wide range of applications, including simple cycle peaking operation, base load combined cycle, demand following in simple or combined cycle, and cogeneration. Because of the different applications, local power market dynamics, and varied emissions regulations by region or jurisdiction, there is a need for operational flexibility of the gas turbine and the combustion system. In 2015, GE introduced a DLN2.6+ combustion system for new and existing 7F gas turbines. Approximately 50 are now in operation on 7F.04 and 7F.05 turbines, combining for nearly 150,000 fired hours. The system has been demonstrated to deliver 5 ppm NOx emissions @ 15% O2, and it exhibits a wide window of operation without significant thermoacoustic instabilities, owing the capability to premixed pilot flames on the main swirl fuel-air premixers, low system residence time, and air path improvements. Based on the success on the 7F, this combustion system is being applied to the 6F.03 in 2018. This paper highlights the flexibility of the 7F and 6F.03 DLN2.6+ combustion system and the enabling technology features. The advanced OpFlex* AutoTune control system tightly controls NOx emissions, adjusts fuel splits to stay clear of instabilities, and gives operators the ability to prioritize emissions or peak load output. Because of the low-NOx capability of the system, it is often being pushed to higher combustor exit temperatures, 35°C or more above the original target. The gas turbine is still meeting 9 or 15 ppm NOx emissions while delivering nearly 12% additional output in some cases. Single-can rig test and engine field test results show a relatively gentle NOx increase over the large range of combustor exit temperature because of the careful control of the premixed pilot fuel split. The four fuel legs are staged in several modes during startup and shutdown to provide robust operation with fast loading capability and low starting emissions, which are shown with engine data. The performance of a turndown-only fueling mode is highlighted with engine measurements of CO at low load. In this mode, the center premixer is not fueled, trading the NOx headroom for a CO emissions benefit that improves turndown. The combustion system has also demonstrated wide-Wobbe capability in emissions compliance. 7F.04 engine NOx and dynamics data are presented with the target heated gas fuel and also with cold fuel, producing a 24% increase in Modified Wobbe Index. The ability to run unheated fuel at base load may reduce the start-up time for a combined cycle plant. Lastly, there is a discussion of a new OpFlex* Variable Load Path digital solution in development that will allow operators to customize the start-up of a combined cycle plant.


Author(s):  
Max H. Baumgärtner ◽  
Thomas Sattelmayer

Volatile renewable energy sources induce power supply fluctuations. These need to be compensated by flexible conventional power plants. Gas turbines in combined cycle power plants adjust the power output quickly but their turn-down ratio is limited by the slow reaction kinetics which lead to CO and unburned hydrocarbon (UHC) emissions. To extend the turn-down ratio, part of the fuel can be converted to syngas, which exhibits a higher reactivity. By an increasing fraction of syngas in the fuel, the reactivity of the mixture is increased and total fuel mass-flow and the power output can be reduced. An Autothermal On-board Syngas Generator in combination with two different burner concepts for natural gas/syngas mixtures was presented in a previous study [1]. The study at hand shows a mass-flow variation of the reforming process with mass-flows which allow for pure syngas combustion and further improvements of the two burner concepts which result in a more application-oriented operation. The first of the two burner concepts comprises a generic swirl stage with a central lance for syngas injection. Syngas is injected with swirl to avoid a negative impact on the total swirl intensity and non-swirled. The second concept includes a central swirl stage with an outer ring of jets. For this burner, syngas is injected in both stages to avoid NOx emissions from the swirl stage. Increased NOx emissions produced by natural gas combustion of the swirl pilot was reported in last year’s paper. For both burners, combustion performance is analyzed by OH*-chemiluminescence and gaseous emissions. The lowest possible adiabatic flame temperature without a significant increase of CO emissions was 170 K – 210 K lower for the syngas compared to low load pure natural gas combustion. This corresponds to a decrease of 15–20 % in terms of thermal power.


2021 ◽  
Author(s):  
Silvia Ravelli

Abstract This study takes inspiration from a previous work focused on the simulations of the Willem-Alexander Centrale (WAC) power plant located in Buggenum (the Netherlands), based on integrated gasification combined cycle (IGCC) technology, under both design and off-design conditions. These latter included co-gasification of coal and biomass, in proportions of 30:70, in three different fuel mixtures. Any drop in the energy content of the coal/biomass blend, with respect to 100% coal, translated into a reduction in gas turbine (GT) firing temperature and load, according to the guidelines of WAC testing. Since the model was found to be accurate in comparison with operational data, here attention is drawn to the GT behavior. Hence part load strategies, such as fuel-only turbine inlet temperature (TIT) control and inlet guide vane (IGV) control, were investigated with the aim of maximizing the net electric efficiency (ηel) of the whole plant. This was done for different GT models from leading manufactures on a comparable size, in the range between 190–200 MW. The influence of fuel quality on overall ηel was discussed for three binary blends, over a wide range of lower heating value (LHV), while ensuring a concentration of H2 in the syngas below the limit of 30 vol%. IGV control was found to deliver the highest IGCC ηel combined with the lowest CO2 emission intensity, when compared not only to TIT control but also to turbine exhaust temperature control, which matches the spec for the selected GT engine. Thermoflex® was used to compute mass and energy balances in a steady environment thus neglecting dynamic aspects.


Author(s):  
Majed Sammak ◽  
Egill Thorbergsson ◽  
Tomas Grönstedt ◽  
Magnus Genrup

The aim of this study was to compare single- and twin-shaft oxy-fuel gas turbines in a semiclosed oxy-fuel combustion combined cycle (SCOC–CC). This paper discussed the turbomachinery preliminary mean-line design of oxy-fuel compressor and turbine. The conceptual turbine design was performed using the axial through-flow code luax-t, developed at Lund University. A tool for conceptual design of axial compressors developed at Chalmers University was used for the design of the compressor. The modeled SCOC–CC gave a net electrical efficiency of 46% and a net power of 106 MW. The production of 95% pure oxygen and the compression of CO2 reduced the gross efficiency of the SCOC–CC by 10 and 2 percentage points, respectively. The designed oxy-fuel gas turbine had a power of 86 MW. The rotational speed of the single-shaft gas turbine was set to 5200 rpm. The designed turbine had four stages, while the compressor had 18 stages. The turbine exit Mach number was calculated to be 0.6 and the calculated value of AN2 was 40 · 106 rpm2m2. The total calculated cooling mass flow was 25% of the compressor mass flow, or 47 kg/s. The relative tip Mach number of the compressor at the first rotor stage was 1.15. The rotational speed of the twin-shaft gas generator was set to 7200 rpm, while that of the power turbine was set to 4800 rpm. A twin-shaft turbine was designed with five turbine stages to maintain the exit Mach number around 0.5. The twin-shaft turbine required a lower exit Mach number to maintain reasonable diffuser performance. The compressor turbine was designed with two stages while the power turbine had three stages. The study showed that a four-stage twin-shaft turbine produced a high exit Mach number. The calculated value of AN2 was 38 · 106 rpm2m2. The total calculated cooling mass flow was 23% of the compressor mass flow, or 44 kg/s. The compressor was designed with 14 stages. The preliminary design parameters of the turbine and compressor were within established industrial ranges. From the results of this study, it was concluded that both single- and twin-shaft oxy-fuel gas turbines have advantages. The choice of a twin-shaft gas turbine can be motivated by the smaller compressor size and the advantage of greater flexibility in operation, mainly in the off-design mode. However, the advantages of a twin-shaft design must be weighed against the inherent simplicity and low cost of the simple single-shaft design.


Author(s):  
Thomas P. Schmitt ◽  
Herve Clement

Current trends in usage patterns of gas turbines in combined cycle applications indicate a substantial proportion of part load operation. Commensurate with the change in operating profile, there has been an increase in the propensity for part load performance guarantees. When a project is structured such that gas turbines are procured as equipment-only from the manufacturer, there is occasionally a gas turbine part load performance guarantee that coincides with the net plant combined cycle part load performance guarantee. There are several methods by which to accomplish part load gas turbine performance testing. One of the more common methods is to operate the gas turbine at the specified load value and construct correction curves at constant load. Another common method is to operate the gas turbine at a specified load percentage and construct correction curves at constant percent load. A third method is to operate the gas turbine at a selected load level that corresponds to a predetermined compressor inlet guide vane (IGV) angle. The IGV angle for this third method is the IGV angle that is needed to achieve the guaranteed load at the guaranteed boundary conditions. The third method requires correction curves constructed at constant IGV, just like base load correction curves. Each method of test and correction embodies a particular set of advantages and disadvantages. The results of an exploration into the advantages and disadvantages of the various performance testing and correction methods for part load performance testing of gas turbines are presented. Particular attention is given to estimates of the relative uncertainty for each method.


Author(s):  
Klas Jonshagen

The common approach for part load operation of a combined cycle power plant is to maintain the turbine inlet temperature as high as possible without exceeding the temperature limits of the gas turbine exhaust. High part load firing temperature will give high cycle efficiency and low HC and CO emissions. The common approach is to reduce the flow by decreasing the compressor inlet flow-angle by turning the compressor variable guide vanes. This is done to control the turbine inlet temperature while the load is reduced by decreasing the fuel flow. However, using the variable guide vanes to reduce the flow renders in an offset of the compressor stage loading which has a negative impact on the efficiency. Compressors are basically volumetric flow machines and if operated on a fixed speed, a change in inlet gas density will alter the mass-flow. This means that if the inlet air is heated, the mass-flow and hence load will be reduced if turbine inlet temperature is kept constant. Thanks to the more or less maintained volume flow the compressor is operated closer to its design point and efficiency remains high. A heat exchanger, preferably with water or steam from the bottoming cycle on the hot side, would be a simple solution to heat the inlet gas. A better use of the available energy would be to semi-close the cycle by recirculating a part of the exhaust gas flow. Semi-closing the cycle means that less oxygen will be available in the combustion process and this will be one of the limiting factors for the recirculation rate. However, the fuel to air ratio decreases at part load and hence the oxygen surplus increases. Therefore, higher recirculation rates may be acceptable at part load compared to full load. The results from this thermodynamic study are very promising and show that a 40% recirculation rate can improve part load efficiency by as much as 4.1%.


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document