Concussion Assessment Across Several Clinical Batteries: Identifying the Components That Best Discriminate Injured Adolescents From Controls

ObjectiveTo identify which sub-components of 4 clinical assessments optimize concussion diagnosis.BackgroundMultiple assessments are part of the clinical toolbox for diagnosing concussions in youth, including the Post-Concussion Symptom Inventory (PCSI), the visio-vestibular exam (VVE), the King-Devick (KD) assessment, and the Sport Concussion Assessment Tool (SCAT-5). Most of these assessments have sub-components that likely overlap in aspects of brain function they assess. Discerning the combination of sub-components that best discriminate concussed adolescents (cases) from uninjured controls would streamline concussion assessment.Design/MethodsParticipants, 12–18 years, were prospectively enrolled from August 1, 2017 to April 29, 2020 Controls (n = 189, 53% female) were recruited from a suburban high school with PCSI, VVE, KD and SCAT-5 assessments associated with their sport seasons. Cases (n = 213, 52% female) were recruited from a specialty care concussion program, with the same assessments performed ≤28 days from injury. We implemented a forward-selection sparse principal component (PC) regression procedure to group sub-components into interpretable PCs and identify the PCs best able to discriminate cases from controls while accounting for age, sex, and concussion history.ResultsThe AUC of the baseline model with age, sex, and concussion history was 62%. The PC that combined all 5 sub-components of PCSI and SCAT-5 symptom count and symptom severity provided the largest AUC increase (+10.6%) relative to baseline. Other PC factors representing (1) KD completion time, (2) Errors in BESS tandem and double-leg stances, and (C) horizontal/vertical saccades and vestibular-ocular reflex also improved model AUC relative to baseline by 5.6%, 4.7%, and 4.5%, respectively. In contrast, the SCAT5 immediate recall test and right/left monocular accommodation did little to uniquely contribute to discrimination (<1% gain in AUC). Overall, the best model included 5 PCs (AUC = 77%).ConclusionsThese data show overlapping features of clinical batteries, with symptoms providing the strongest discrimination, but unique features obtained from neurocognitive, vision, and vestibular testing.

Age-Related Vestibular Dysfunction; Vestibulo-Ocular Reflex, Dynamic Visual Acuity, Dizziness and Falls: A Review

Background: Vestibular and vision functions are important contributors to posture control and fall avoidance. This review examines how the vestibulo-ocular reflex can be rehabilitated to help restore postural control. Methods: PubMed searches (7th April 2021) using the terms ‘vestibulo-ocular reflex’, ‘imbalance and vestibular dysfunction’, ‘vestibular dysfunction and dizziness’, ‘dynamic visual acuity’, ‘vestibular dysfunction rehabilitation’, and ‘gaze stabilization exercises’ yielded 4986, 495, 3576,1830, 3312, and 137 potentially useful publications respectively. Selections of those which were found to be the most relevant and representative of a balanced and current account of these topics, as well as selections from the most relevant reports referenced in those publications, were included in this review. Results: Just as there are age-related losses of static visual acuity even when there are no specific visual pathologies diagnosed, patients may also present with age-related loss of vestibular functions in the absence of specific vestibular pathologies. For example, cases of dizziness which are diagnosed as idiopathic might be usefully classified as age-related as the basis for the initiation of rehabilitation exercises. Conclusions: Apart from age-related loss of vestibular functions, cases diagnosed as having a particular form of vestibular pathology may have that condition exacerbated by age-related losses of vestibular functions. The effects of vestibular rehabilitation gaze stability exercises in patients with vestibular dysfunction are well established and include both improved dynamic acuity and postural stability. Improvements in posture control following rehabilitation of the vestibulo-ocular reflex are apparently due to improved peripheral and/or central vestibular balance control which has occurred in conjunction with enhanced gaze stability. The complex nature of increased fall risk suggests that an interdisciplinary approach to rehabilitation that includes vestibulo-ocular reflex rehabilitation appears likely to be associated with optimum outcomes for both pathological and age-related cases.

Isolated Floccular Infarction with Impairment of High-Frequency Vestibulo-Ocular Reflex: A Case Report

The flocculus plays a crucial role in control of eye movements. Based on animal experiment, it is suggested that the flocculus is important for governing vestibuleocular reflexes. In humans, an isolated floccular lesion is extremely rare. We report oculomotor abnormalities in a patient with unilateral infarction of the flocculus, and compare our results with those of previously reported patients with floccular lesion.

VestAid: A Tablet-Based Technology for Objective Exercise Monitoring in Vestibular Rehabilitation

(1) Background: Current vestibular rehabilitation therapy is an exercise-based approach aimed at promoting gaze stability, habituating symptoms, and improving balance and walking in patients with mild traumatic brain injury (mTBI). A major component of these exercises is the adaptation of the vestibulo-ocular reflex (VOR) and habituation training. Due to acute injury, the gain of the VOR is usually reduced, resulting in eye movement velocity that is less than head movement velocity. There is a higher chance for the success of the therapy program if the patient (a) understands the exercise procedure, (b) performs the exercises according to the prescribed regimen, (c) reports pre- and post-exercise symptoms and perceived difficulty, and (d) gets feedback on performance. (2) Methods: The development and laboratory evaluation of VestAid, an innovative, low-cost, tablet-based system that helps patients perform vestibulo-ocular reflex (VORx1) exercises correctly at home without therapist guidance, is presented. VestAid uses the tablet camera to automatically assess patient performance and compliance with exercise parameters. The system provides physical therapists (PTs) with near real-time, objective (head speed and gaze fixation compliance), and subjective (perceived difficulty and pre- and post- exercise symptoms) metrics through a web-based provider portal. The accuracy of the head-angle and eye-gaze compliance metrics was evaluated. The accuracy of estimated head angles calculated via VestAid’s low-complexity algorithms was compared to the state-of-the-art deep-learning method on a public dataset. The accuracy of VestAid’s metric evaluation during the VORx1 exercises was assessed in comparison to the output of an inertial measurement unit (IMU)-based system. (3) Results: There are low mean interpeak time errors (consistently below 0.1 s) across all speeds of the VORx1 exercise, as well as consistently matching numbers of identified peaks. The spatial comparison (after adjusting for the lag measured with the cross-correlation) between the VestAid and IMU-based systems also shows good matching, as shown by the low mean absolute head angle error, in which for all speeds, the mean is less than 10 degrees. (4) Conclusions: The accuracy of the system is sufficient to provide therapists with a good assessment of patient performance. While the VestAid system’s head pose evaluation model may not be perfectly accurate as a result of the occluded facial features when the head moves further towards an extreme in pitch and yaw, the head speed measurements and associated compliance measures are sufficiently accurate for monitoring patients’ VORx1 exercise compliance and general performance.

Report of oscillopsia in ataxia patients correlates with activity, not vestibular ocular reflex gain

BACKGROUND: Patients with cerebellar ataxia report oscillopsia, “bouncy vision” during activity, yet little is known how this impacts daily function. The purpose of this study was to quantify the magnitude of oscillopsia and investigate its relation to vestibulo-ocular reflex (VOR) function and daily activity in cerebellar ataxia. METHODS: 19 patients diagnosed with cerebellar ataxia and reports of oscillopsia with activity were examined using the video head impulse test (vHIT), Oscillopsia Functional Index (OFI), and clinical gait measures. Video head impulse data was compared against 40 healthy controls. RESULTS: OFI scores in ataxia patients were severe and inversely correlated with gait velocity (r = –0.55, p < 0.05), but did not correlate with VOR gains. The mean VOR gain in the ataxic patients was significantly reduced and more varied compared with healthy controls. All patients had abnormal VOR gains and eye/head movement patterns in at least one semicircular canal during VHIT with passive head rotation. CONCLUSIONS: Patients with cerebellar ataxia and oscillopsia have impaired VOR gains, yet severity of oscillopsia and VOR gains are not correlated. Patients with cerebellar ataxia have abnormal oculomotor behavior during passive head rotation that is correlated with gait velocity, but not magnitude of oscillopsia.

Incremental Velocity Error as a New Treatment in Vestibular Rehabilitation (INVENT VPT) Trial: study protocol for a randomized controlled crossover trial

Background A clinical pattern of damage to the auditory, visual, and vestibular sensorimotor systems, known as multi-sensory impairment, affects roughly 2% of the US population each year. Within the population of US military service members exposed to mild traumatic brain injury (mTBI), 15–44% will develop multi-sensory impairment following a mild traumatic brain injury. In the US civilian population, multi-sensory impairment-related symptoms are also a common sequela of damage to the vestibular system and affect ~ 300–500/100,000 population. Vestibular rehabilitation is recognized as a critical component of the management of multi-sensory impairment. Unfortunately, the current clinical practice guidelines for the delivery of vestibular rehabilitation are not evidence-based and primarily rely on expert opinion. The focus of this trial is gaze stability training, which represents the unique component of vestibular rehabilitation. The aim of the Incremental Velocity Error as a New Treatment in Vestibular Rehabilitation (INVENT VPT) trial is to assess the efficacy of a non-invasive, incremental vestibular adaptation training device for normalizing the response of the vestibulo-ocular reflex. Methods The INVENT VPT Trial is a multi-center randomized controlled crossover trial in which military service members with mTBI and civilian patients with vestibular hypofunction are randomized to begin traditional vestibular rehabilitation or incremental vestibular adaptation and then cross over to the alternate intervention after a prescribed washout period. Vestibulo-ocular reflex function and other functional outcomes are measured to identify the best means to improve the delivery of vestibular rehabilitation. We incorporate ecologically valid outcome measures that address the common symptoms experienced in those with vestibular pathology and multi-sensory impairment. Discussion The INVENT VPT Trial will directly impact the health care delivery of vestibular rehabilitation in patients suffering from multi-sensory impairment in three critical ways: (1) compare optimized traditional methods of vestibular rehabilitation to a novel device that is hypothesized to improve vestibulo-ocular reflex performance, (2) isolate the ideal dosing of vestibular rehabilitation considering patient burden and compliance rates, and (3) examine whether recovery of the vestibulo-ocular reflex can be predicted in participants with vestibular symptoms. Trial registration ClinicalTrials.gov NCT03846830. Registered on 20 February 2019.